The deep human malady

Are people essentially good, basically corrupt, or somewhere in between? How to assess our human reality? By our own opinion? Our evaluation would tend either to hubris or low self-esteem, because, bizarrely, there is in our nature both good and evil. Our pride would emphasise the good; our realism may recognise the bad also. 

The difficulty is, you cannot truly understand yourself by yourself. This is the eternal conundrum already long before Blaise Pascal, he who excelled in “showing how vile and how great man is” (§119/423). He also had deep insight into the real cause of both our nobility and our baseness. The dual nature of man, he saw, has its explanation par excellence in the Bible, and he expresses it as if God was telling us: “It is I who have made you, and I alone can teach you what you are. But you are no longer in the state in which I made you. I created man holy, innocent, perfect… He was not then in the darkness that now blinds his sight, nor subject to death and the miseries that afflict him. But… he wanted to make himself his own centre and do without my help. He withdrew from my rule, setting himself up as my equal in his desire to find happiness in himself, and I abandoned him to himself” (§149/430).

In other words, our positive glory comes from being part of the unique species that was created in the image of God; our deep depravity comes from the fact that humankind has fallen away from that original holiness. This is the light from God that we need to make sense of our dual reality. God’s glorious creation is in ruins; and the fault is not God’s! Man has become a rebel: “men are the devils of the earth” (Schopenhauer). “Humans have a great capacity for wrong-doing,” wrote Jordan Peterson, a “proclivity for malevolent actions. Every person is deeply flawed. Everyone falls short of the glory of God” (12 Rules for Life, p.55 and p.62). And Malcolm Muggeridge stated, “The depravity of man is at once the most empirically verifiable reality, but at the same time the most intellectually resisted fact”. Yes, we resist it, don’t we? Yet in our sober moments, we must acknowledge it is true. “All have sinned”, says the Bible: “None is righteous” – in the sense of being perfectly good in God’s eyes (Romans 3.10, 23). And if we think we are the exception, the Bible brings us back to reality: “If we say we have no sin, we deceive ourselves and the truth is not in us” (1 John 1.8).

We have said that God is our Creator, but he did not make us inherently evil; he made humankind in his image, in the likeness of a holy, good and loving God. That is the source of our inherent greatness. The source of our inherent sinfulness is due to a primeval rebellion, the disobedience of the first human couple, Adam and Eve.

That deserves separate treatment.

Clive Every-Clayton